PDM roundtable examines the regulation of political advertising online

The Popular Democratic Movement (PDM) has hosted a roundtable on the regulation of social media political advertising, bringing attention to a fast-changing part of democratic life. The discussion centres on how political parties, technology companies, regulators and citizens can protect open debate while limiting deception, hidden sponsorship and manipulation in digital campaigns.

For audiences in Australia, the subject has immediate relevance. Political messages now reach voters through Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, search engines and encrypted messaging services, often with little of the context that accompanied newspaper advertisements, television commercials or a candidate’s speech at a community hall. A campaign message seen in Sydney may be targeted at a narrow group in Brisbane or Melbourne and disappear before the wider public can examine it.

The PDM’s broader work connects the conversation about online campaigning with democratic accountability, civic participation and social justice. Its public policy material, parliamentary activity and engagement with young people provide a framework for considering how political communication can remain transparent while still allowing parties and citizens to use modern tools.

Why political advertising needs public scrutiny

Digital advertising has changed the scale and speed of election communication. A campaign can test different slogans, images and videos with small audiences, then increase spending on the versions that generate the strongest response. This may help parties speak to voters about local concerns, but it can also make public debate fragmented. Two neighbours may receive entirely different claims from the same campaign and have no easy way to compare them.

The commercial data market adds another layer of complexity. Advertising platforms can use location, browsing behaviour, interests and inferred characteristics to decide who sees a political message. Some targeting categories may be supplied directly by users, while others are produced by automated systems. The result can be persuasive communication that feels personal without making its sponsor, funding source or intended audience clear.

A roundtable provides a useful setting for testing these concerns against practical realities. Regulations must protect political expression rather than give an incumbent government a convenient method for silencing critics. At the same time, voters need enough information to identify paid content, understand who authorised it and assess whether a claim has been altered for a particular group.

Disclosure should be visible and meaningful

A basic safeguard is a clear political advertising disclosure. Voters should be able to see the name of the party, organisation or individual responsible for an advertisement, along with information about who paid for its distribution. Disclosures hidden behind several clicks do little for a person scrolling quickly through a mobile feed. The label needs to be readable in a video, image, audio clip or promoted post.

The same principle applies to third-party campaigns. Trade unions, industry groups, advocacy organisations and wealthy individuals may spend heavily to influence an election without appearing on a ballot paper. A strong system should reveal the financial relationship behind a message, including the use of agencies, consultants and intermediary organisations. Public registers can help journalists and citizens trace spending across platforms.

Australia already offers a familiar reference point through authorisation requirements for election material. Federal political advertising generally needs an authorisation statement, although the exact rules depend on the type of material and the election involved. Digital content can make these requirements harder to enforce, especially when advertisements are modified automatically or distributed through accounts based outside the country. A consistent, prominent disclosure standard would make the rule easier to understand in the local market.

Tackling misinformation without suppressing debate

The regulation of political advertising must distinguish between false information, satire, opinion and legitimate criticism. A government-appointed body should not become the final judge of every political claim. That approach could chill vigorous debate, particularly for smaller parties, independent candidates and community campaigns that lack the resources to challenge an adverse decision.

There are still responsible ways to address demonstrably deceptive material. Platforms can maintain searchable political ad libraries, record the dates and locations in which an advertisement appeared, and preserve earlier versions when a message is edited. Independent fact-checking, rapid corrections and penalties for impersonation can operate alongside free political discussion. Deepfake audio and video deserve particular attention because they can create convincing fabrications in the short period before polling day.

Australian voters have seen how quickly online claims can travel during federal elections, state campaigns and referendums. A misleading post shared in a local Facebook group can reach thousands through private forwarding before a correction gains visibility. The answer is not to remove every disputed statement, but to create a transparent process that identifies paid influence, preserves evidence and gives affected people a fair opportunity to respond.

Protecting privacy and vulnerable audiences

Microtargeting raises privacy questions that go beyond ordinary advertising. A political campaign may infer a person’s health concerns, religious beliefs, ethnic background, financial pressure or likelihood of voting. Even when a platform does not disclose the underlying data, the advertisement can reveal that a campaign has classified its audience in a sensitive way.

A sound regulatory model should restrict the use of sensitive personal information for political persuasion and require clear consent where data is collected directly. It should also limit targeting based on children’s profiles and prevent campaigns from exploiting people facing hardship. The Australian Privacy Act and related reform debates provide an important reference for this discussion, although electoral communication has distinctive features that require specific safeguards.

Accessibility matters as well. Political advertising should be available in formats that can be understood by people with disability and, where appropriate, by culturally and linguistically diverse communities. A multilingual audience in Western Sydney, Melbourne’s northern suburbs or regional Queensland may encounter different messages according to language and location. Transparency must include the ability to see what different communities are being told.

Platforms, parties and regulators share responsibility

Social media companies play a central role because they control advertising tools, recommendation systems and access to data. They should publish clear political advertising policies, verify sponsors, label synthetic media and provide researchers with meaningful information about reach and targeting. Voluntary promises can be useful, but they are unlikely to provide consistent protection during a closely contested election.

Political parties also have responsibilities. Internal approval processes should require campaign teams to check factual claims, identify sponsors and keep records of audience targeting. Candidates should be accountable for contractors and advertising agencies acting on their behalf. A party’s digital strategy should respect the same standards of honesty and public responsibility expected at a press conference, a parliamentary statement or a community meeting.

Regulators need powers that match the technology without becoming political actors. An independent electoral authority could monitor disclosure, investigate coordinated deception and require platforms to preserve relevant records. Enforcement should be proportionate, with stronger penalties for deliberate impersonation, foreign interference, hidden funding and the repeated publication of fabricated material. Public reporting would help voters judge whether the system is working.

The PDM’s parliamentary focus on fairness also provides a wider lens for these questions. Its discussion of equal pay debate illustrates how policy issues depend on visible evidence, public accountability and the ability of citizens to evaluate competing positions. Those same principles apply when a political message is delivered through a sponsored post rather than a parliamentary speech.

Building informed participation beyond election day

Regulation will be strongest when it is supported by civic education. Voters need practical guidance on recognising sponsored content, checking an image’s origin, finding an ad’s sponsor and reporting suspicious material. Schools, libraries, community organisations and public broadcasters can help people develop these skills without turning media literacy into partisan instruction.

Public participation should also extend beyond formal election periods. Political advertising can shape views on budgets, public services, industrial relations and national development long before a writ is issued. Parliamentary committees, civil society forums and local consultations can invite communities to discuss acceptable standards before a crisis forces hurried action.

Cultural expression offers a useful reminder that democratic communication takes many forms. A public artwork such as a giant memorial mural can carry historical memory and political meaning without operating as paid advertising. The distinction matters: regulation should focus on sponsored influence and deceptive distribution, not treat every civic expression as a campaign transaction.

For Australians, the debate can connect digital rules with everyday political habits: local candidate forums, talkback radio, multicultural festivals, union meetings and the familiar exchange of views at a weekend barbecue. Online advertising now sits alongside those traditions rather than replacing them. A trustworthy framework should allow new voices to participate while ensuring that money, data and automated systems do not decide which voices become visible.

The PDM’s public record and PDM policy documents offer a point of reference for following its positions on governance, transparency and citizen engagement. A well-regulated digital environment should reflect those values by making political persuasion more open to scrutiny, protecting personal information and giving voters a clearer account of who is speaking, who is paying and how the message reached them.