PDM calls for debate on decriminalising street trading

The Popular Democratic Movement (PDM) has called for a parliamentary debate on the decriminalisation of petty street trading in Namibia. The proposal asks lawmakers to examine whether minor vending offences should be removed from the criminal justice system and replaced with administrative rules that protect vendors’ livelihoods while keeping public spaces safe, clean and accessible. It is a debate about dignity, economic opportunity and the proper role of the state.

For many residents in Windhoek and other towns, small-scale trading is an essential source of income. Vendors may sell fruit, vegetables, cooked food, household goods or handmade items from temporary stands or mobile stalls. When such activity is treated as a criminal matter, a single fine or arrest can interrupt a household’s daily work and deepen the sense that public space belongs to some citizens but not to others.

A parliamentary debate would allow the issue to be considered openly rather than through repeated arrests and municipal enforcement actions. Affected traders, residents, businesses, disability advocates and local authorities should be able to present evidence, identify practical problems and propose a framework that regulates street activity without criminalising poverty.

Why petty street trading belongs before Parliament

Petty street trading sits at the intersection of several public responsibilities. Municipal authorities manage sanitation, traffic flow, pavements, markets and public safety, while Parliament determines the laws that local officials administer. Removing criminal penalties does not remove those responsibilities; it changes the legal tools available and places Parliament directly at the centre of the reform.

Debate is particularly important because the language of the law affects how enforcement is carried out. “Illegal trading” can sound like a description of serious disorder, yet many cases involve a vendor earning a modest income, operating without a costly permit or failing to meet a technical requirement. Parliament should ask whether prosecution is proportionate, whether alternatives are accessible and whether enforcement can create corruption risks where discretionary powers are poorly supervised.

Decriminalisation and the meaning of social justice

Decriminalisation of petty street trading is fundamentally about equal treatment. Traders who work in city centres, markets and transport corridors should not face harsher consequences simply because they lack formal premises or capital. Legal recognition can give vendors a clearer route to permits, mediate disputes and challenge arbitrary enforcement without requiring them to enter the criminal justice system merely to seek a livelihood.

This approach also recognises that the right to trade is connected to economic inclusion, although it does not guarantee anyone a particular place on a pavement. Namibia’s history of exclusion, uneven urban development and high unemployment makes the distribution of public space a serious equity question. A policy that allows participation in the formal economy, while treating informal traders as suspects, can deepen divisions between connected businesses and those serving poorer communities.

The reported Trelew survivor judgment concerning state compensation for a survivor of the Trelew massacre is relevant to a wider understanding of public power. Democratic institutions earn legitimacy when they protect people, acknowledge harm and provide effective remedies. The same principle applies to ordinary municipal enforcement: the state should not merely punish vulnerability, but use transparent procedures to protect vendors and the communities who share crowded streets.

Windhoek’s streets and the municipal balance

Windhoek’s streets carry commercial, transport and social functions at once. A trader may provide affordable food and convenient services to residents who have limited access to formal retail, while poorly managed stands can obstruct pavements, waste collection and accessible routes. Any reform must take these competing needs seriously rather than presenting vendors or residents as opposing groups with no shared interest.

Municipal rules can still be necessary, but enforcement should be predictable and proportionate. Requirements concerning designated trading areas, permits, food preparation, waste disposal and operating hours should be clear before penalties are considered. Vendors should receive information in relevant languages, have a practical way to correct mistakes and be able to appeal decisions that affect their ability to trade.

The local government’s role should include enabling infrastructure, not only policing conduct. Waste points, water access, toilets, storage facilities and affordable stall spaces can reduce many of the problems associated with unauthorised vending. Regular forums between the municipality, vendor associations and residents can surface local knowledge that a national debate alone cannot capture, including the needs of people with disabilities and customers who value convenient access to goods.

Lessons from Australia’s urban markets

Australian cities offer a useful comparison because busy public spaces are paired with rules on footpath activity, mobile food businesses, waste and street trading. The lesson is not to copy one local by-law, but to see how administrative controls can make small trade visible and accountable without routing routine municipal disputes through criminal court.

In Melbourne, hospitality businesses operate from narrow laneways where mobile coffee carts, delivery riders, bins and queues compete for limited room. Melbourne City Council’s footpath controls illustrate a familiar Australian approach: specify where trading may occur, protect clear passage and apply safety rules through licensing and compliance. Windhoek can consider similar spatial plans while keeping permits affordable for small operators.

Queen Victoria Market shows the relationship between established and small-scale commerce. Its formal stalls, fresh produce sellers and busy aisles create a valuable trading environment, while nearby pavement activity reflects demand for affordable goods and services. Australian farmers’ markets, seasonal fruit vendors and community stalls offer lawful spaces for small producers, provided they have stable arrangements rather than arbitrary toleration.

Sydney’s inner-city footpaths and waterfront precincts add the challenge of balancing tourism, dining, deliveries and pedestrian movement. Adelaide’s Central Market similarly depends on formal shops, food businesses, street activity and transport flows meeting in one place. These examples suggest that markets thrive when rules reflect how a location functions. Namibia can consider limited trading zones, low-cost permits and municipal support informed by the needs of informal settlements.

A lawful framework for vendors and residents

Parliament should consider decriminalisation as the removal of criminal liability for minor vending conduct, accompanied by a fair administrative scheme. This distinction prevents a regulatory vacuum. It also gives authorities legitimate tools to address genuine public dangers while reducing the likelihood that routine poverty-driven trade will be handled through criminal records, court time or detention.

A workable model could include simple registration, affordable permits for designated areas, exemptions or lighter rules for low-value activities, and proportionate penalties for obstruction, sanitation failures or refusal to comply with reasonable directions. Food traders may need additional hygiene and inspection requirements, but those standards should be consistent and explained clearly. Vendors operating temporarily at community events should not be forced into the same process as permanent market tenants.

Enforcement should follow a staged approach. Verbal guidance and correction should come first where the risk is minor; civil or administrative penalties can follow repeated non-compliance; prosecution should be reserved for serious conduct posing a substantial public danger. Independent complaint mechanisms, published schedules of offences and an accessible appeals process would help ensure that regulation remains accountable to the people it affects.

Transparency, representation and parliamentary oversight

Parliamentary oversight should cover both the decision and its consequences. PDM can urge lawmakers to invite a public position paper, evidence from municipal authorities and affected groups, and produce a clear account of the reforms under consideration. The discussion should identify data such as prosecutions, permits issued, complaints lodged and revenue collected from small traders.

PDM’s published party leadership structure provides the institutional starting point for engagement. Transparency about which representatives receive submissions, which institutions have been consulted and how dissent will be recorded can reduce the temptation to treat informal traders as a politically convenient nuisance.

A committee could require a regulatory impact assessment before new rules take effect. Vendors should help shape it. Revenue from permits should support waste management, market facilities and trader support where feasible, with regular reporting on how the money is used and whether enforcement outcomes are fair.

Moving from parliamentary debate to reform

The immediate goal should be a structured debate with a defined public mandate. PDM can urge lawmakers to schedule the discussion, release evidence in advance and invite submissions from small traders, market associations, municipalities, disability organisations and residents. A published response should explain which proposals will be pursued and which require further consultation.

Action should then follow through a timetable for reviewing municipal vending rules, drafting amendments and training enforcement officers. Pilot projects in selected areas could test affordable permits, improved waste collection and transparent enforcement before a national model is adopted. Success measures should include fewer criminal cases for minor trading, better compliance with public-space standards, increased vendor income and greater confidence in procedural fairness.

A humane response to street trading recognises that economic survival and public order must be managed together. Parliamentary debate offers Namibia a route to replace punishment with participation, giving vendors a lawful place in the economy while protecting the shared spaces on which urban life depends.